[unscientific teaching in louisiana *science* classes]
In May last year I blogged about the Creation musueum that had just opened in Kentucky devoted to telling the history of the world...according to the bible. Well, know there's the Louisian State Education Act "is designed to slip ID in "through the back door", says Forrest, who is a professor of philosophy at Southeastern Louisiana University and an expert in the history of creationism. She adds that the bill's language, which names evolution along with global warming, the origins of life and human cloning as worthy of "open and objective discussion", is an attempt to misrepresent evolution as scientifically controversial.Forrest's testimony notwithstanding, the bill was passed by the state's legislature - by a majority of 94 to 3 in the House and by unanimous vote in the Senate. On 28 June, Louisiana's Republican governor, Piyush "Bobby" Jindal, signed the bill into law. The development has national implications, not least because Jindal is rumoured to be on Senator John McCain's shortlist as a potential running mate in his bid for the presidency.
***
Supporters of the new law clearly hope that teachers and administrators who wish to raise alternatives to evolution in science classes will feel protected if they do so. The law expressly permits the use of "supplemental" classroom materials in addition to state-approved textbooks. The LFF is now promoting the use of online "add-ons" that put a creationist spin on the contents of various science texts in use across the state, and the Discovery Institute has recently produced Explore Evolution, a glossy text that offers the standard ID critiques of evolution (see "The evolution of creationist literature"). Unlike its predecessor Of Pandas and People, which fared badly during the Dover trial, it does not use the term "intelligent design".
Because the law allows individual boards and teachers to make additions to the science curriculum without clearance from a state authority, the responsibility will lie with parents to mount a legal challenge to anything that appears to be an infringement of the separation of church and state. "In Dover, there were parents and teachers willing to step forward and say, this is not OK," says Rosenau. "But here we're seeing that people are either fine with it or they don't want to say anything because they don't want to be ostracised in their community."
Read the full article at New Scientist.
NB some of the comments in relation to this article in NS are hilarious while others are deeply saddening.
Labels: bible, christianity, education, philosophy, politics, religion, science, usa


jess @ jesslaccetti.co.uk




8 Comments:
In other news, pi equals 3 and we stick to the Earth because we love it so much.
It really bugs me that people seem to view religion/creationism as an opposition to scientific theory. Religion is speculation and faith. Just because some parts of existence are known and are explainable, it doesn't mean that they dispute any attempts to explain the unknown.
I'm a Christian and I have no trouble accepting scientific facts just because they're different to what I'm "supposed to believe".
As some random person once said "I've no problem with God, i's his fan club I can't stand"
I know. It does seem pretty crazy. Especially as Louisianna is bringing this kind of teaching into the curriculum by citing academic freedom...however is creationism or intelligent design (gosh that term is hard to say) really "academic"?
oh my god is right jess. what is with these americans? just pure craziness!
ben
I went to religious schools all my life and it was never an issue learning the 2 theories. One was taught in religion class and one was in science class where we could talk openly about it, what a novel concept!!! We even had discussions about both in the classes, it made us all open to other ideas and enriched us.
Regardless of how much the US says that the Church and State are separate, what they do is completely different!
hi anon,
what was it like learning about intelligent design...was that in religion class? how did the teacher approach it.
and btw: in what country did you receive you education? does that make a difference?
Hey Jess,
It was taught in Religion class but also mentioned in science classes. When we were learning about Darwinism, for example, the teacher mentioned that the Bible has a difference stance but both can be correct. Religion class taught Creationism and then we had discussions about it. The teachers always taught us to question what we were told, this of course led to very lively discussions and a better understanding of Religion and Science.
I am from Canada. I do believe that the area you receive your education from makes a big difference.
Jo-Ann
Hi Jo,
How did the teacher explain the differences between ID and science? What were the general reactions of your classmates? It sounds great that there were lots of lively discussions. I'm curious in science how your teacher brought in the idea of creationism?
I must have blanked out high-school but I don't remember anything about creationism in my religion classes...
Hi Jess,
You must have zoned out all those years!!!!!!! Gee the stories I can tell :)
Anyway, mostly in Biology but also the other science classes we would be talking about evolution of some species and either some smart ass kid would say well the Bible does not agree with it, or the teacher would bring it so we would talk about how there are 2 theories and talk about the merits of both. Depending on who was in your class it could get very vocal but usually it was very calm and interesting. I am sure you know which Biology teacher was the best for these conversations and his thoughts on it :)
In religion class we would talk about God being the creator of everything so once again the topic of evolution would come up. All the teachers I had were very good in saying that both are very valid and to never discount an entire theory just because you do not know the facts. It was left up to everyone of us to make our own conclusion on which we would give more merit to.
Does that help jog your old memory :P
Jo-Ann
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home